June 9, 2025

What you need to know about influencer marketing in Canada

By
Heylist Team
It’s easy to envy the massive splash U.S. brands make with influencers. Glossy partnerships, global reach, and million-dollar budgets. But if you’re a Canadian brand, the path looks a little different—narrower markets, tighter budgets, and a regulatory landscape that’s still catching up. Despite its growing maturity, influencer marketing in Canada poses some unique challenges. From niche market constraints to scaling inefficiencies, let’s unpack what’s holding Canadian brands back—and more importantly, how to get unstuck.

Finding the right influencer-fit in niche markets

Canada’s population sits at just under 40 million, which means most verticals here operate on a smaller scale. This magnifies the risk of misalignment. For example, a wellness brand based in Vancouver looking to target Francophone Gen Z in Montreal has to dig deep to find creators who meet that exact profile. Generic influencer platforms often lack this level of granularity.

Solution: Lean into hyper-local search and segmentation tools. Partner with platforms or agencies that offer detailed audience insights and localized creator databases. Niche doesn’t mean impossible—it just requires precision.

Budget management while maximizing reach

Canadian brands often operate with modest influencer budgets compared to U.S. counterparts. The challenge? Stretching dollars across content creation, usage rights, paid amplification, and reporting. Brands frequently over-invest in one-off macro-influencers or underutilize long-tail creator relationships.

Solution: Shift toward nano and micro creators with higher engagement rates and build long-term partnerships. A consistent collaboration with a $500/month creator can outperform a $5,000 one-time post.

Measuring ROI beyond vanity metrics

Engagement rate. Follower count. Likes. These are easy to track but rarely show the full picture. The deeper challenge is tying influencer efforts to business outcomes—think conversions, retention, and customer lifetime value.

Solution: Set clear campaign goals at the outset and integrate UTM tracking, affiliate codes, and post-campaign surveys. Use tools like Shopify Collabs or Heylist to link creator activity to sales impact.

Navigating compliance and regulation

Unlike the U.S. FTC, Canadian influencer disclosure guidelines are more ambiguous. While the Competition Bureau advises transparency, enforcement has been sporadic, leaving brands and creators in legal gray zones.

Solution: Don’t wait for enforcement. Proactively require clear disclosures (“#ad”, “Sponsored by”) and educate partners on best practices. Legal risk isn’t just about fines—it’s also about trust erosion.

Scaling operations without burning out your team

Once brands crack the influencer code, scaling becomes the next bottleneck. Managing dozens of creators across contracts, briefs, approvals, payments, and reporting can become a full-time job.

Solution: Invest in CRM-like tools designed for influencer workflows. Automate where possible (e.g., contract templates, bulk payments) and consider hiring or outsourcing to influencer ops experts.

Final thoughts

Canadian brands have all the right ingredients for influencer marketing success: authentic products, culturally rich audiences, and creators who punch above their weight.

But cracking the code requires a shift in mindset. Think local, act strategic, and scale smart. Because in Canada, effective influencer marketing isn’t just about going viral—it’s about creating resonance that lasts.